Fallout 4 VR - Great game with Technical Issues

Hello fellow VR fans,

If you follow VR at all, then unless you've been under a rock this past week, you'll know that Fallout 4 VR was finally released this week.

As someone who has finished the "pancake" version of Fallout 4 twice, I pre-ordered the VR version the instant it was announced by Bethesda and came up on Steam. I am a massive Fallout fan and was completely overjoyed to learn that it was being re-released for Steam. Even the £40 ($60) price tag didn't put me off in the slightest.

However, I knew there was a risk about how good a port this would turn out to be, but I decided to just go with it.

This blog post is about my first 3 days playing Fallout 4 VR.

Performance

Perhaps the biggest question coming from people that don't currently own the game is "How well will it run on my system?"

If you read the likes of the Steam discussion forums and Reddit r/vive, there are many many complaints of people with high-end systems say they have performance issues. Comments like "I have a 1080ti and <decent processor> and I am only getting 45 fps/massive reprojection/etc" are rife.

And I do find it a bit strange, because I have exactly the spec for general entry-level VR, an Intel i5-4590 and Geforce GTX 970, and I find the game to be totally playable with no supersampling (Wikipedia) and TAA (Wikipedia) off (more about that later). Of course, I am getting reprojection (Wikipedia), a lot of it, and with the graphics running at native Vive resolution and no anti-aliasing (Wikipedia), it is quite pixelated (Wikipedia), but it is still definitely good enough for me to forget all that after 5 minutes and just get lost in the game.

So, without intending to unduly trivialise the experiences other people are having, I can't help but feel a lot of peoples' experiences fall into one of three scenarios:

• People with high-end specs are used to getting zero reprojection in normal made-for-VR games and are just focusing on the data rather than just feeling how the experience is. There is a suggestion that perhaps people on low-end specs, like me, have less expectations and therefore less likely to be disappointed.
• People have ganked their configs with dodgy tweaks killing their performance, and then complain it is the game's fault.
• People just liking to complain that, at the end of the day, this is a port of an already known-to-be flawed/old gaming engine. It was never going to be awesome work of art in VR because it was never awesome on the flat screen.

I repeat, I have an i5-4590 and GTX 970 and I'm loving playing Fallout 4 VR. I do not deny, however, that this game is challenging to deal with from a performance perspective, I'm not say people with high-end rigs aren't right to expect better.

Technical Issues

The second biggest thing (a close second) are the technical issues.

It has to be said that Fallout 4 VR has released with some head-scratching bugs. Head-scratching because they don't seem to be particularly fundamental issues, and one is really left wondering how such issues could have been missed.

Case 1: On release, the rendering resolution in the game was locked to what your current desktop resolution was. It was a really crazy problem that was causing a wide range of issues. For me, my desktop runs at 1080p, so the result for me was really crappy looking graphics but reasonable performance. Other folks with 4K displays were finding they had great looking graphics but really crappy performance, because the 4K desktop resolution was effectively supersampling the crap out of the graphics.

It's such a crazy bug, why on Earth the desktop resolution should have anything at all to do with the rendering on the VR headset is just totally bizarre, as is how such as bug could be missed before release.

The plus side on this is that this issue proved Bethesda was completely poised to resolve early issues, and they released a Beta patch for this problem within 14 hours of game release. They have continued to release 2 further issue-resolving patches up to now as well.

Case 2: TAA is really a problem. TAA is the default anti-aliasing algorithm Fallout 4 VR uses to smooth the graphics, and it looks blurry as hell. It seems to me that TAA is something that works perfectly well on the flat screen, but no-one in Bethesda did too much research into how well it looks on displays 1 inch from your eyeballs.

TAA on - Everyting is severely blurred.

The Reddit/Steam communities saved the day with that one, with a simple console command to turn off TAA and either just leave all AA off (like I currently do) or use a different better anti-aliasing method like SMAA.

TAA off - Sharp but severe pixelation

Bethesda seem to be focusing on resolving supersampling issues as a way to resolve graphics problems than messing about with anti-aliasing, which is fine. I'm on a low-end system anyway so I chose to just leave TAA off for best performance and deal with the pixelation.

Case 3: The most annoying bug for me, the tendency for the game to crash when performing certain container inventory actions. I have been getting crashes to desktop when trying to retrieve an item from a crafted container in my home hub of Sanctuary, plus now also getting crashes when just opening a random container out in some location in the Commonwealth. Bethesda released another Beta patch late last night that I haven't had chance to test yet, but it purports to resolve inventory crashing problems so I am hopeful this problem is also fixed.

So, this whole saga seems like we are on the bleeding edge, and you might call it bleeding edge if Bethesda was the first company to port a pancake game to VR, but Croteam showed how it is done with their Talos Principle VR port, so one wonders a little about Bethesda's approach to all this.

Bottom line is, if you feel like you can wait a little while before buying Fallout 4 VR, or want the price to drop, then you can probably avoid all this community enthusiasm for solving these technical issues.

I stress again, however, I am still loving Fallout 4 VR despite all this, I am a technical person so I can deal with these issues, and whatever their faults, Bethesda are watching community comments like a hawk and resolving issues fast, so they at least deserve credit for that.

Case 4: Scopes do not work, period. The scope lens renders opaque, so you can't look through them. Bethesda says they are going to fix that in an update, but we don't know when. So you are limited to iron sights like the glow sights or reflex sights for now.

The Gameplay Itself

I'm not going to go into what Fallout 4 is like in general, you can read any number of reviews for the original game for that, but rather the VR-conversion specifics.

It's a bit of a mish-mash really. The hand controllers are fully integrated, which is a massive plus, but, well, it would be dumb if they weren't, so you are fully capable of doing everything you need to in the game fairly intuitively. I do struggle a little with the over-sensitivity of the Vive touchpads, but it's a minor inconvenience.

Combat in particular is fun. You can smack things with melee weapons or even pistol-whip baddies by just waving your weapon around with the controller. Guns seem to handle well, despite even the huge ones being one-handed. Aiming is a bit odd, in general there seems to be an "RPG effect" where you can get your aim spot on, but there is still some "chance to hit" applied which may or may not cause your bullet to shoot at a slight angle to where you are aiming. You can look down the iron sights and fire a gun and see the bullet go off to one-side. It seems to be the same mechanic as when playing the "pancake" version, where you can see bullets spray around your target reticle. It doesn't work so well in VR though, but it's not such a big issue, especially when you are also using VATS to fight.

The biggest missed opportunity, I won't say disappointment, is the vast majority of interactivity with the game world is still via menus, albeit floating menus. Get stuff in and out of a container? Floating menu. Interact with an NPC? Floating menu. Remove a power core from a generator? Floating menu. Pick up an item in the game world? Point at it and click "pick up." There is only basic tactile interactivity with the world, even picking up objects to move them around is odd at the moment (likely to be fixed later I should think). I guess, with such a huge game to deal with, Bethesda felt this was the best approach, but it is the biggest missed opportunity to me. It's not something I find myself focusing on when playing so it doesn't get in the way, but still, I hope there are mods developed that bring some of these factors into the game.

Floating displays are core to gameplay - functional but not immersive.

Conclusion

I think choosing to buy Fallout 4 VR right now really depends on the type of person you are.

If you are like me, which means you *love* the Fallout and Elder Scrolls series, you are a VR nut, you have technical ability (and perhaps by that I mean real IT experience and/or know-how as opposed to being just some Joe who is as likely to break something by tinkering than improve it), then Fallout 4 VR is totally worth it. Despite the issues, I have no regrets about paying £40 for it and getting stuck right in.

If, however:

• You expect a game to just work when you buy it, which is quite reasonable and, ironically, the basis I have previously reviewed a lot of Indie games.
• Don't agree with paying top-dollar for what could be argued is still a work in progress (again, reasonable).
• Are expecting Fallout 4 VR to be some pinnacle of technical achievement. I'm not really sure why this should be the case but a lot of folks on the forums seem to be acting this way.
• Just can be arsed with all the bugs(back to being reasonable again).

Then waiting for a while before you buy is probably wise. I'm not sure if Fallout 4 VR will go into a sale price over the Steam Winter sale but it might be worth just to wait a couple of weeks and see.

I, however, am not disappointed!

Dark Legion VR Review (Verdict: Good, Shame About the Bugs)

Hello my fellow VR enthusiasts,

We have another game review for today, Dark Legion VR.

I actually don't remember how this game got into my library, I think I must have picked it up on a freebie. It's a shame I couldn't find out for sure, because when you can get your money's worth out of this game depends on whether you paid a very small amount or got it for free.

Which doesn't bode well I know. However, this game does have some redeeming features that at least might merit some further interest if you can pick it up for a steal. It's not as bad as some other rock-bottom VR titles, like the awful Marlene Act 1 Betwixt I reviewed in my last post.

Dark Legion VR - The Plot

Orange leather doesn't stop her from getting left behind.

As is often the case with Indie VR titles, the plot for dark legion VR is quite thin. I've seen worse, however.

You appear to be some kind of space mercenary. You start off the game in your main ship, in a training arena, with your ridiculous orange-leather-bound female companion there also. Your companion takes you on a walk around the area showing you all the features, and then there is an achievement for completing certain tasks in the shooting range and other areas.

Actually, as far as tutorials go, it's quite well done. There was only one thing I wasn't sure about, because there were not any visual cues as to whether I was doing the exercise right, but otherwise it's a great introduction into using the weapons.

So you go on your first mission and, whilst you are in your shuttle, something goes wrong. You crash land and need to find a spare part to fix your shuttle and move on.

Whilst looking for a spare part (in the middle of nowhere) you start getting attacked and you apparently quickly forget about your shuttle (and companion) and go wondering off trying to find the source of the aggression.

The Game Mechanics

Thankfully, I found the core gameplay for Dark Legion VR to be very enjoyable. Weapons work well and you soon get into a rhythm of managing shots left and reloading. Combat is urgent but geared such that you aren't forgetting yourself and running into your real world walls trying to dodge projectiles. As you get further into the game you can slip into a well-worn cover and shoot mechanic to battle most of the enemies, and every so often the game tosses into something slightly different to shake up the gameplay, such as snipers you can't simply shoot from far away, riot shields that block standard bullets, and bosses where you are forced to get out of cover and take on much more directly.

So despite some depressingly familiar bugs, which is why this game doesn't actually get a thumbs-up rating (explained later) the core game entertained me well enough that I stuck with it through the bugs and to the end. It's about 3 hours gameplay and so, if you are picking this up for a pittance, not bad value.

More Details

The pistol is great fun to use, and the iron sight works well.

With the high level overview of this game explained, I will slip into the good, the bad and the ugly for more details.

The ugly first:

• The game crashes on every level transition, including when defeating the last boss. Normally, it autosaves right before the crash so you can just reload the game, jump back in and carry on. On killing the end boss however, the game crashes instantly (again) and when you reload, it dumps you in an empty boss room with no way to progress, so.... you don't actually get to see the end game movie/credits/whatever.
• It bears repeating, on top of crashing in-between every level, I persevered through the crashes and my reward was to know I beat the game but never get to see the ending.
• As many others have stated, the dumb little flying robot is idiotic, it frequently gets right in the way of where you want to shoot whilst you are getting shot back.

Now the good a.k.a. why I persevered with this game:

• The graphics in the game are pretty good. They aren't outstandingly beautiful, and they are a little basic, with a lot of flat surfaces. However, the graphics do work well, particular for seeing and aiming at things at reasonable distances. Visual cues are also apparent without standing out like a sore thumb.
• I actually quite like the main duck/cover and shoot mechanics on how you do most of the fighting. It's a bit contrived, with extremely basic enemy AI particularly, but nonetheless I quite enjoyed ducking in and out, popping off a few shots and reloading.
• Weapon selection and reloading is again nicely done for the most part. You can pick up weapons off your belt in either hand and use the other hand to pull clips from the back of your belt, pop the clip in the gun and, depending on the gun, also pull the lever to prime the gun and start shooting.
• In particular the pistol, which is the first weapon you get, is great fun to use (although that is also a bad thing).
• The bow as well is quite well done. It's been done well in other games too but it works well here also.
• Depth perception is spot on, which means you can shoot from the hip, shoot round corners, but also use iron sights very effectively for well placed headshots.

It's a shame this robot is bullet-prood, stupid little git.

Finally, the bad (or perhaps just not so good):

• Although the graphics are quite good, the sound is a little lacking. Sound effects are basic although monster noises do a good job of alerting you of what's around the corner. The music is quite dreadful however. Mostly it is background noise, but the overly dramatic music on boss fights grates after you hear the one minute song on loop for the fifth time.
• The controller-trigger activity depends on the context of what your hand is pointing at, and the game can get very confused. If you are struggling to pick up a gun from your belt, it's probably because your hand is pointing at something on the floor or wall you can interact with.
• Weapon balancing is iffy. I spent most of the time using the pistol because it is a) easy to reload b) has no spread, c) the iron sights are extremely accurate and d) the pistol has infinite ammo. The shotgun is little more than useless, the automatic rifle has too much spread, you only use the bow when you need to because drawing arrows takes time, and the rocket launcher is squandered if you use it on anything except bosses.
• The sniper rifle is worth singling out. It has a top-mounted zoom display so you can try those round-the-corner shots. However, the zoom level is quite high and my hands are just not steady enough to use the rifle effectively. There has to be a way to solve a lack of steadiness for long-range weapons in VR games, it's not like you can lean on anything to steady yourself.
• Your female companion, who helps you through the initial tutorials, is ridiculously dressed. The arse-tight leather and pointy nipples will appeal to the young lads I'm sure.

The game breaking level-transition bug is a real shame, because that is what stops me from giving this game a thumbs-up. However, without such a stupid bug, Dark Legion VR is a fun little Indie game that is fun to while away a few hours in, so I don't have the heart to give it a thumbs-down either.

Marlene Act 1 Betwixt - (Verdict: Avoid)

Hello fellow VRHeads, today I will be reviewing the game "Marlene Act 1 Betwixt", a game I think I must have picked up for free, which is just as well really.

It's quickly going to be apparent as you read this, that I don't think much of this game.

The Marketing

On the Steam Store page, the game describes itself thus:

"Marlene is a tense and immersive psychological horror story in which you star as the protagonist Ewan Brody. Ewan is on his way to visit his estranged sister at her remote cottage after hearing the news that his Niece Marlene has gone missing or possibly something worse. . ."
I'm very grateful to read this description actually because you get no clue about what is supposed to be happening by actually playing the game.

The Game Premise as Actually Played

Why is this man standing on top of the house? Who knows?

So what plot do you get from playing the game? Well, you start off in courtyard, at night, and you are holding a torch (a flashlight, for my American friends). The torch is a really odd looking thing, it's not a traditional torch. I did wonder if it is trying to be a torch function on the back of a mobile phone. After looking at it for some time, I came to the conclusion that it is meant to be a card torch, something like this.

And trying to work out what this thing you are holding is sums up the plot to this game. It really explains nothing to you. Things in the game are unusual and somewhat random. I mean, why a card torch? Why not just a regular torch? What is the point of this little detail?

And that's what you get from this game, weird details with no explanation.

The Game Mechanics

And the randomness with no explanation outlines the game mechanics as well. You basically spend your time plodding around, picking up random crap hidden in dark corners. Odd things happen without explanation; at one stage you get a bookshelf on a wall to fall down by... standing underneath the other bookshelf in the room. The bookshelf that falls down has the key you need to get to the next room.

Why does this room suddenly catch fire? Who cares?

How does that make any sense?

And that is all this game is, plodding around, doing random stuff until a solution presents itself. At one stage I climbed up a ladder onto a flat roof to pick up something up there, and then got stuck because I couldn't work out how to get down again, because apparently just climbing down the ladder I came up is too straightforward.

There is a review on Steam by the user Bee that sums up this game really well.

"I found this game really aggravating. It's like a demo for VR that's really in love with picking up books and soda cans. The play is one pixel-hunt after another, and your reward for finding the pixel is a jump scare. The story is a cliche, the sounds and music are very primitive (free downloads, I think) and objects, including critical objects, can clip through floors and walls and get stuck.

Have you ever wanted to try and find the marble in the oatmeal, while dodgeballs rain down on your head? This game has that experience, for some reason."

I couldn't have said it better myself.

This Game Highlights the Problem with the Indie VR scene.

Poor cabin owner can't afford more than basic furniture

I have to be very blunt here, this game resonates as a minimum effort project to create a really basic VR game "shell", just chuck in some low quality sounds and objects and just put in a few triggers. Then call it a game.

This game is the very epitome of all that is wrong in the Indie scene for VR games. Because of the relative lack of quality games in the VR market today, this game is the crap you have to sift through in order to find those gold nuggets. This game cheapens the market and makes it all the more difficult for those independent developers and game studios who *do* create quality titles, to get the kudos they deserve. The quality titles out there are lost in a sea of the mediocre, to the outright dreadful.

Going back to my section on the marketing of this game, I've never been so disgusted with the use of the word "immersive." The only way you can call this game immersive is that, by the act of putting on the VR headset and injecting yourself in this world, you are there. The only truth to the word "immersive" here is the basic technicality that this is a VR game.

Consider the value this game would have if it was not a VR title, but a regular PC indie title. It would be something some enthusiastic teenager would knock up in a bid to try and start a career in being an independent game developer. If that is the case, then kudos to that person as an individual, but I'm reviewing this game as a serious gamer. I potentially could have spent money on this.

So Who is the Developer?

Well, if you look up Uzi Games on Google, you arrive here. So at this stage I feel a little apologetic for my scathing review, because the website does say that this is a one-man show. Although I stand by my review, actually I have respect for anyone trying to make a go of something ambitious. The website does show this guy has another game in development, I have to hope this title is a lot better than Marlene.

Although then I read the review snippets he has for both of his games and I start to lose sympathy again.

“There are quite a number of VR psychological horror games out at the moment and Marlene is certainly one of the best.” - The Reality Sandwich

I can only think there must have been almost nothing else out on the market at the time.

The Verdict

If you have slightly masochistics tendencies, then get this game for free, lose 30 minutes of your life to it until you ask yourself, "What's the point?" and then you can at least say you tried it yourself to see if it really is bad.

If you are not masochitic, or if this game is not free (currently it is £1.49), then avoid! Take your £1.49 and use a dice to buy another game for the same price. You already rolled a one with this game, so a random pick cannot be any worse.

The Talos Principle VR (Verdict: Top Quality)

Welcome back everyone.

It's been a while since I have posted on my blog. I apologise, work and other duties have kept me occupied, and my home study had managed to accumulate various junk, which took me the longest time to clear. As any Vive player knows, it's hard to play VR unless you've got the clear space.

Another thing that had frustrated me was I was planning on doing a big review on Fallout 4 VR, but the release date for that has now been pushed back to December.

Luckily, my timing was good enough to coincide with the release of The Talos Principle VR. I must admit I didn't even realise this was being worked on, I've been so far out of the loop of late. However, I have previously completed and platinumed Talos Principle on PS4, so when I saw this released on Steam, I snapped it up straight away, despite my previous penny pinching nature with trying to buy discounted games. 😛

So on to the review.

What is The Talos Principle?

The core plot of the Talos Principle essentially sees your game character as being an avatar of yourself. In other words, you could be him, he could be you. Neither you nor your character has any idea what is going on, so what's to do except start plodding around? It isn't long before a voice starts giving you instructions about what's going on.

The Jammer: One of the core puzzle solving tools.

As you explore, you come across messages in various different formats, the voice in the sky keeps talking at you, and also another "character" starts talking to you, and it's left to you to make sense of it!

So that's the plot, now for the game mechanics. Basically, this is a puzzle game with an excellent plot wrapped around it. The game consists of hub worlds that connect to levels, and each level contains a number of puzzles to solve. The majority of the puzzles are of the nature that you are in an arena with various obstacles, gates, switches, etc and you need to get to the "end" of it to claim your prize, which is a kind of jigsaw piece. Once you start building up pieces you can unlock further areas via solving tetris-style puzzles, where you get a set number of pieces and have to fill the board with them with no spaces.

The plot and the puzzles combine well. The puzzles teach you to think outside the box a little, and if you apply that lateral thinking to the overall game world and the plot, you can move off the well-trodden path to some interesting new areas with new things to discover.

I don't want to say any more, you can tell I'm being a little vague already, but the whole point of the game is to start from knowing nothing, and as the Talos Principle is a great game, you should play it, whether it is on a traditional format if you don't have VR, or on your VR headset.

For more in-depth coverage of the core game, here are reviews from 2 major gaming magazines on the Talos Principle (non VR version).

• Gamespot (written review) - 9/10
• IGN (video and written reviews) - 8.3/10 

The Talos Principle in VR.

The Connector - Notice the robotic hand? That's your hand!

Firstly, this game in VR is an example of a rare full-on triple A title for your VR headset. It is the entire game, plus the Road to Gehenna DLC, rendered very well in VR. The game controls have been adapted so they make intuitive sense using your hand controllers. Also, there are very few bugs and for those bugs that do exist, they are mainly cosmetic. If you complete this game to the maximum extent there are many 10s of hours of gameplay here. At £29.99, there can be no argument that you are paying a fair price for a full game, unlike many VR "experiences" where you can pay half as much for a tenth of the game time.

The other huge plus for this game is that the developers, Croteam, have worked on making the VR experience as customisable as you want it. There are options for being able to turn around with the controls or have that disabled (so you physically have to turn around yourself), several different types of locomotion, an option to click or just touch the touchpads to move, an option to always run or only move as fast as you press, and more. Even if you have some comfort issues with playing VR for a length of time, if this game can't solve them then I don't know what game will.

The only tempering points I can raise about playing this game in VR is that although it is a great overall VR experience, it doesn't add any additional sense of presence when you play it, as opposed to playing the traditional non-VR format. Some VR experiences can feel totally different and more personal, especially the horror genre, but there is little extra sense of immersion playing Talos Principle in VR.

Also, you don't actually have to really physically move around that much. Room scale is only useful for perfectly positioning yourself in front of a touch puzzle or terminal. You mainly play the game just standing, and after a few hours my legs start to ache. You'll probably stop playing when you want to sit down for a bit, rather than any motion issues.

So, is it Recommended?

Solving a puzzle in VR. Your controller is the hand.

Regarding my points about the lack of  VR "addition" to the experience, I should stress again this comes from someone who played The Talos Principle on PS4 to 100% completion, and I am still very much loving going through this game again in VR.

Even though:

• I've played this game before
• My previous experience was on PS4 so I have to pay full price on Steam (if you have the original Talos Principle on Steam you get a 25% discount off the VR version)
• Historically I've been a bit stingy paying top whack for VR games.

I very much recommend The Talos Principle to all PC VR headset owners. On the PS4 I considered this game to be one of the most enjoyable platinums I've ever achieved, and going through it all again in VR is a total pleasure!

VorpX Virtual Screen & Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Hello fellow VR lovers,

As explained in previous posts, VorpX is a great bit of software that lets you turn your legacy games into VR experiences. The results vary a fair bit, from Borderlands, which to me just looks 3D but not really immersive, to Fallout 3 where it really feels like you are there. Setting these games up right takes a fair bit of tinkering most of the time, but the results can make it really worthwhile.

However, there are some games where no amount of tinkering helps you get the right result. Sometimes these are because of technical issues with the game, and sometimes it is because the game itself just doesn't translate well to seeing it in first person in VR all the time. This is where VorpX's virtual screen mode comes into play.

What is Virtual Screen Mode?

What DE:HR in Virtual Screen mode looks like

In standard VR mode you are looking at the game through the eyes of your character. You can turn your head to look around, you'll see your guns being held up in front of you and generally the desired result is to feel like you are in the game world.

In Virtual Screen mode, the game is running in a large virtual screen placed in front of your view point. The effect from a VR-perspective is similar as if you were playing the game in your own virtual cinema, and indeed you can easily configure VorpX to draw you sitting in a chair in front of the screen, and draw a theatre room around you. Look down and you can see your (drawn) legs.

The point of this mode is to enable you to still play games in 3D even if they don't lend themselves to being played in full VR mode. It's the same as if you were playing on a 3DTV or a 3D-enabled monitor. But if you don't have a 3D monitor and you do have a VR headset, this is for you!

In this post I talk about how it was to set up Deus Ex: Human Revolution, and what the results are like.I chose DE:HR because there are many third person view elements in this game, such as the cover mechanism which you use extensively if you play this game in stealth mode (i.e. the proper way). This means even if you got this game working smoothly in VR mode, you are not going to get the full experience because you'll get many issues in relation to switching to third person mode all the time.

Technical Issues Abound in VorpX and the Game

The basic setup of this game is actually fairly easy, the problems are the technical issues you have to overcome. The game engine itself is quite solid and stable, the specific problems are around the graphics.

Actually, the Deus Ex engine has a 3D mode built-in. The trouble is, it is tied around nVidia 3D Vision and other 3D monitor-based solutions, and I didn't find any way to enable this for use with a VR headset. So you might as well ignore this feature.

Turning off DX11 is currently needed due to a VorpX problem

There appears to be in a bug in VorpX at present that really kills performance in some Direct X 11 games, and I discovered this bug trying to play DE:HR. It doesn't matter what performance improving tweaks you try such as lowering the resolution or switching away from geometry 3D mode, the game runs like crap. You have to switch to DirectX 9 mode, which luckily you can do directly in the game options rather than have to mess about in some config file.

The good news is, in DirectX 9 mode, DE:HR runs really well. The bad news is, we have another technical problem to resolve. For some strange reasons, Geometry 3D mode in DirectX 9 causes shadows to render out of position. The shadows for one eye are too far left and the shadows for the other eye are too far right. Disabling shadows in the game does not resolve this issue, because all objects in the game have lighting effects and the shadows option only covers actual shadows cast onto the ground. The other big problem with this mode is you get permanent "shadow" bars on the left and right side of the screen.

The solution to this problem is to switch from Geometry 3D mode to Z-Buffer 3D. Unfortunately, you do lose some of the very sharp depth perspective you get with G3D mode, but overall the game looks better because the shadow problem is solved.

Finally, at this stage you probably notice that whilst the game looks fine, you'll chop around a lot between getting great frame rates and some really bad stuttering. Unfortunately you can blame Eidos for this one. The original DE:HR game had a patch that solved these problems, but Eidos created the Director's Cut version based on a pre-patched version of the original and so these bug have returned. The worst part is, now the Director's Cut version has been out for several years, clearly Eidos are not going to re-patch the game, thanks a lot Eidos!

Luckily, our friends on the internet have some simple tweaks that resolve a lot of the issues, although you'll need to be comfortable editing the windows registry. The tweak is explain in this post on the Steam community, but the those already familiar with RegEdit, all players need to make the following change

• Go to HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Eidos\Deus Ex: HRDC. Change AllowJobStealing to 0.

And if you are an nVidia card owner (like me) you also need to make the next change as well.

• Go to HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Eidos\Deus Ex: HRDC\Graphics. Set ATIForceFetch4 to 0.

The Results

After all this work, the game is great fun to play in 3D. It's pretty similar to watching 3D movies in BigScreen actually, a great way of taking a 3D screen principle and getting it to work in your VR headset.

At some point in the future I'm going to try the same thing with the original BioShock (not the remastered version). I've tried getting it to work in VR before and although technically I have got it there, I was never able to fix the zoomed-in/POV problem. Using virtual screen seems like a good idea!

Until next time!

VR Escape the Room Trilogy (Verdict: Avoid)

Hello VR Followers, for today's review: The VR Escape the Room Trilogy.

VR Escape the Room Trilogy.

These 3 games aren't a trilogy in terms of any continuity, only that they are 3 escape room games from the same developer that likely use the same engine. At the moment you can buy them in a bundle with 57% off in the Steam sale, which peaked my interest enough to take a chance on them.

To explain to the uninitiated, escape rooms are where you are put into a locked room, and in order to escape you have to solve puzzles that build up to letting you open the exit, whether it is finding keys, numbers to a keypad code, whatever.

In fact escape rooms are a new trend in real life as well. I haven't been to one in the UK yet, but I have been to 2 in the US and 1 in Israel and I can tell you the general experience is very similar, it's just the setting and puzzles are different. I do quite like escape rooms because they appeal to the puzzle solver in me, so this is another reason I was interested in these games.

A key difference to real life vs VR escape rooms is that in real life you tend to be a team locked in the room, whereas in VR you are on your lonesome.

A Bad Experience

Don't drop a book on the floor, you won't be able to pick it up again! WTF?

Unfortunately, this game series did not work well for me. I only actually played The Cabin: VR Escape the Room and then I asked for a refund. I will tell you why.

If you look in the Store Page for this game, you will see the words "This VR game requires a play area of at least 2.1m x 1.8m." My play area is 2.3m by 2.2m, should I should be fine, right?

Wrong. The game operates by relying completely on room scale to let you move around the VR space, there is no other method of moving in the game except to physically move yourself. This is what it is important that you have sufficient space.

The problem is, the game does not render the VR world properly into your space. For me it was off centre, and the result was that one of the walls was rendered about 30cm past my real wall. I managed to play the game for a bit, but then found a button on this wall that I needed to press, and I couldn't because my real wall stopped me from getting there.

So I couldn't continue, stopped dead by a technical issue.

Another thing I found is that the VR world's floor was rendered about 20cm below my real floor. The result of that is that if you drop books on the floor, you can't pick them up.

I say this to the developers, "Come on guys!" If you are going to create a game that relies on room scale then you can at least make sure the game world maps properly onto the real world, otherwise
what is the point?

So it is a thumbs down and a recommendation on me to avoid this series of games. I don't care if the bundle is 57% off, if the game is technically unplayable it could be £1 for all I care. Luckily, Steam gave me a refund (good ol' Steam, they have never done me wrong).

I've been on Steam since Half Life 2 came out and now I've only ever claimed 2 refunds. One for The Solus Project and now one for this game bundle. This shows you what a crap shoot the VR game industry is right now.

The Solus Project Review (Verdict: Avoid)

Hi everyone,

The first game I am reviewing from my Steam bargain list is The Solus Project. Despite what I said in my Steam sale post about not wanting to burn through the games quick in a rush to review them, I've spent 3 hours on The Solus Project and I'm not going to play it any more. The reason for this is a game breaking bug which has no place being in any commercial release. Skip to the section titled "The Game Breaker" if you want to jump straight to finding out what it is, but I strongly recommend steering clear of this game until you see this bug is fixed (which based on an Internet search demonstrating this problem going back over a year, is unlikely to be any time soon).

The Premise

The background for The Solus Project is that Earth has been destroyed by a wandering rogue star. Scientists saw it coming a couple of decades ahead of the actual event and so life vessels were built and a fraction of the population managed to escape to regroup near Pluto. Exploratory vessels have been sent into deep space in order to find new planet to colonise.

However, after years of travel disaster strikes (of course). As you are approaching your destination planet, your ship is destroyed and you manage to escape and crash land in a life pod. This is where the game starts, you have to learn how to survive and try to contact your people to let them know what happened.

If the crash land and survive premise sounds a bit familiar, this is because it's basically the same as Subnautica. Different world and different type of game (diving underwater vs on land) but yeah, it seems this is a bit of a cliché. The VR market is full of them!

Playing the Game.

The game babysits you through the first hour to form a tutorial on how to play. First steps sound very textbook. Find shelter, food and water, make fire for heat and light.

The weather is one of the highlights of the game world - extremely threatening

Shelter is very important in this game because the planet does have extreme weather. Rains come in with only the warning of rolling clouds from the horizon and typically feature dangerous lightning, tornados are also too common and you even get meteor showers. The weather effects in The Solus Project are very well done and carry a real sense of concern. You will find yourself strongly motivated to stop what you are doing and find some shelter nearby to wait out the storm. As well as food and drink, your character has to sleep to survive. Storms can take hours of in-game time to pass so what else is there to do but catch forty winks while you wait for it to blow over?

Once you finish the first survival steps the game prods you into exploring the area, trying to find survivors and work out how you can communicate to your people off-planet. After some time spent being in this mindset, you'll quickly realise that survival is in fact largely trivial in this game. Food and water sources are plentiful, at least in the first few hours, and your biggest problem is managing the very small inventory space you have when you start. I guess it is realistic not to be able to hold much, and you can upgrade your storage by finding backpacks in wrecked bits of ship and life pods. But after going so heavy on the survival element and making you think you need to horde food and water, you realise that actually travelling light is the best option. All you need to do is run for cover when the weather comes in and, hey, you're surviving just fine on this supposedly hostile planet.

The game prods you into your first few discoveries, you find another person in their camp and see they were also trying to build a way of communicating off planet and then the game helps you with getting the first few parts. Then all the help stops suddenly.

As someone who doesn't necessarily need to be hand-held through open world games, I explored for the next hour and had a very good time before I saved and finished my gaming session.

Graphics and Sound

The day and night skies are very pretty

I always start with sound in these sections because it seems easier to review 😁. The sound in The Solus Project is very atmospheric. The high points are when you are suffering the extreme weather, you can hear the wind whipping around you, rain falling hard, meteorites striking all around you. Other than the weather however, sound is relegated to plodding steps, the bing of some piece of tech nearby, the sound of fire on your old-school torch and the movement of wind.

The graphics in the game are quite detailed and successfully immerse you into this somewhat barren landscape. However, much like sounds outside the storms, none of it is particularly memorable in the first few hours. Landscapes are convincing if dull, the dark sky at night is very pretty with stars and during the day quite beautiful with the alien planets close up in the sky. The skies are well done, but you don't spend much time looking up in this game so you soon forget the sky. Landscapes are barren, caves dull. Again, I guess this is realistic, but it's not very exciting. Overall, however, you do have to say the overall immersion is of a very high standard.

The game engine seems to run well. I don't recall much in the way of stuttering, no SteamVR loading screens randomly popping in, load times are deliberate and only occuring during area transitions, the game runs fine, except....

The Game Breaker

Having played for 3 hours I decided to save and finish my session. The game focusses on realism and I was having enough fun to want to keep exploring and see what happens next. So I was looking forward to starting up again the next day.

The next day, I loaded the savegame, and appear 20 feet under ground level and I start falling away from the game world. Hoping this is a one-off, I reloaded again, and the same thing happened. I reloaded a third time just in case, same thing again.

So basically my save is corrupted and I can't continue.

The game has an autosave feature so I tried that. The save loads fine, but the autosave was during the last area transition, and I probably played 1 to 1.5 hours and completed a whole bunch of tasks before I manually saved, so that is not good enough.

The game has a device which allows you to teleport short distances, so I wondered if I could use that to reload and quickly teleport back above ground again to salvage my savegame. I tried maybe 20 times, but the device does not behave predictably in this unpredictable situation, so it is no good.

So I uninstalled the game and I won't be going back for now.

There is absolutely no excuse for this kind of ridiculous save-breaking game-breaking bug in a game which is £14.99 at full price. This save game corrupted at the end of my first play session. If it is going to happen that soon in the game then it could be a common bug for all I know, and I'm not going to risk my game time with that. Indeed, a very quick search on Google brings up multiple results with other players having the same problem, results going back more than a year.

This is exactly what I am talking about when I say you take a risk every time you buy an Indie VR game. I can't say I have ever come across such a heinous and ridiculous save corruption bug before. Even in Bethesda games like Fallout and The Elder Scrolls series which have been glitchy in their time (particularly Fallout 3 and Fallout: New Vegas), the game developers cover this by giving you multiple regular autosaves so although it can be annoying, the worst that can happen is you lose 30 minutes of gameplay.

This is why I'm taking the opportunity during the Steam sales to buy these games. I would have been absolutely raging if I'd spent £14.99 on this only for it to crap out after 3 hours. As it stands, at £7.49, I'm still going to try for my first ever Steam refund, I'm not content to patiently wait potentially another year to see if they'll fix this problem.

Verdict

I am disgusted with such an awful game-breaking bug. A very quick search on Google shows that this is a fairly common problem that has been going on for at least a year, and it still isn't fixed.

I have to recommend to everyone to avoid buying this game, discounted or not!

Avoid!

Subnautica Review (Verdict: Excellent)

Hello folks,

Those of you who read my blog (thank you) will know that I've said the next sentence time and time again: I'm very wary of spending full game price on VR games, because the quality is so varying.

Prior to the Steam Summer Sale (see previous post), I only purchased one VR game. I did this after having pretty much exhausted the most obvious free games and experiences on Steam, and only after a lot of research.

The game I bought was Subnautica and I paid £14.99 for it. It is currently 50% discounted on Steam at the moment, so until July 5th you can buy it for £7.49.

Technically Subnautica is in "Early Access" release, which means it is not a finished game. However, as you can see in the Subnautica Blog, it's been in development for a few years already, so even though there's still a lot of polish that can be added, it is already a great in-depth experience that you can spend many many hours enjoying and exploring.

So What's Subnautica About?

The basic premise of the game is that your space ship has crashed landed whilst you were in the vicinity of a water planet. Luckily, your life pod ejected before impact and saved your life, managing to absorb it's own landing and successfully inflate the bouyancy aids. This is where you begin the game, you have literally just landed and you need to start working out where you are and what you need to do to keep yourself alive.

As soon as you venture outside, you realise that water effectively covers 100% of the planet surface and therefore all life is in the sea, returning back inside your life pod and checking the replicator, you can start to learn what resources you need to gather to construct basic survival tools.

The game has various modes to suit the type of gamer, but in the default Survival mode, you need to eat and drink to stay alive, and also you need to breathe, which as this game is mostly underwater, is probably the biggest challenge out of eat/sleep/breathe to manage.

How the Game Plays

Food and water, whilst being an important factor in survival mode, is not such a great task to manage. As long as you keep a check on your levels and make sure you keep a stock of water specifically, you don't really need to worry too much about staying on top of these. Before you set out for a long expedition, as long as you've fed and watered yourself and you keep a small stock in your inventory, you'll be fine.

It's really oxygen that defines how you play this game. To start off with, you can hold your breath for 45 seconds, which really means you begin by swimming in the shallows and the range of your exploration is taking expeditionary dives underwater to explore specific areas of the sea bed or to gather resources. Pretty soon you can craft a basic oxygen tank, which whilst only giving you an extra 30 seconds, makes a big difference to your underwater scuba diving. The next big initial step is that it is not too long before you can build a small submarine vessel. The vessel produces oxygen for you, which means now you can go deeper and explore much more, and only need to worry about your oxygen level when you leave your craft to gather some resources or enter a confined space.

The limitations of oxygen and this slow-but-steady development of your abilities really define how the game works overall. Initially you are presented with a very limiting factor, by exploration and trial-and-error you can understand how to overcome that challenge, then that part becomes easy and you move onto the next task. Thus, you can start to explore more and more of the world and get further into the game.

The other main method of advancement is technology. Using a tool you create fairly early in the game, you can start to gather blueprints based on stuff you find lying around when you explore, and this lets you build better and bigger things.

The Subnautica World

The Subnautica world is a beautiful and exciting place to explore in VR. The world is made up of different biomes where different flora and fauna live and there are several times when you get a new sense of wonder at new creatures you find as you explore further and deeper. I won't give up further details on this because it will spoil the game, but there have been several times when I have stopped what I was doing and just swam around a new creature in amazement because I'd never seen anything like it before in the game.

There is also a genuine sense of danger in exploring the seas, something that I think VR enhances. When diving into the deeper spaces, concern for oxygen is genuine. That cave over there that looks like it twists and turns, how far do you explore before you worry about if you can get back in time? Also, not all the sea life is friendly and there are creatures in this game that will either have you instantly concerned if you spot them first, or will put you into a panic if they manage to creep up on you.

Your space ship was large and other life pods were ejected. You get a helping hand in the first hours of the game as your lifepod computer picks up on signals from the surrounding area and invites you to explore them. It's possible that there are some other survivors and even if there are not, there might be some tech you can scavenge to help your own situation. Plus, the space ship crash landed in shallows and is always in view, perhaps you can visit what's left of the hull and find out why it crashed.

There is a basic plot to the game, which you are gently nudged along in the early parts of the game thanks to the signals your lifepod picks up, but really you are never pushed to follow it. Furthermore, after you receive a bunch they just stop, and then you are really left up to your own devices. Personally, although I like being able to explore freely and not be confined to the story, I can't help but feeling it is a bit too light in Subnautica. Exploring or not, I always like to know what I need to do next to get further along in the story, and after a while you are really left just to work it out yourself.

Graphics and Sound

The sound in Subnautica is spot on. Various creatures have their own sounds and the audio cues in the game are sometimes even more important than seeing things. In particular, hearing the sound of a predator will have you checking around so you are sure you know what it is doing. Also, the rush of water around your ears when you dive underwater really makes you feel like you are submerging yourself thanks to how the world around you genuinely sounds like you are now hearing it through water. Overall the sound effects and music give a very immersive feeling of really being in the world.

As I said before, Subnautica is undeniably beautiful. However, this is sometimes thanks to the overall immersion rather than the technical quality of the graphics. Sea life tends to always be rendered well and moving realistically, but distance pop-in is a real problem. The Length of Distance view in this game is actually quite short, and not only will you see things popping into view all the time, but sometimes you need to more closely explore an area just so you are close enough to see what you are actually looking for. It's an issue but one that can be lived with.

The other major issue with the graphics is that this game is quite unoptimised. I don't have a beefy VR rig, in fact mine is technically entry level, but nonetheless, I don't typically have too many issues with frame rates in games. With Subnautica, however, frame rates do chug all too often, and not always with any apparent good reason like there's a lot going on. In the worst cases, you can see the SteamVR busy/loading graphic pop up and really I think there is no space for this to be happening in any "proper" VR game. I suspect this is the main factor with the game being in early access. The graphics are beautiful, but the game engine needs a lot of polish. Still, I find I can easily look past these issues and stay genuinely immersed.

Overall

Despite any issues with the graphics and the plot, I heartily recommend Subnautica to VR headset owners. There is a full scale world to explore, the graphics and sound are beautiful even if the game engine needs polish, and I especially like the underwater survival element of the game.

I bought this game at full price and having probably spent 20-30 hours on it already (and feeling like I am nowhere near the end), it is definitely value for money. The game being early access might put some folks off, and it did me originally, but the developers don't give any signs as to when they'll make the 1.0 release and really I think you are doing yourself a disservice if you hold off buying Subnautica just for that reason.

Steam Summer Sale Now On

Full Disclosure: I am not affiliated with Steam in any way, nor do I gain any commission from anything in this blog post, I am merely a happy customer!

Attention all HTC Vive and Oculus Rift owners, the Steam Summer sale is now on!

If you've looked out for previous sales, then you will be well aware of the tradition of picking up multiple games for bargain prices, only to ever play about 25% of what you bought!

Well, if you are like me and you don't normally like to pay full game prices for VR experiences, which can either be short or so-so in quality, then this Summer Sale also means something else, the opportunity to take a chance on some VR games without worrying about wasting too much money on games you end up not liking!

In just the first couple of days I have already picked up the following.

Game	Original Price	Discount	Sale Price	Saving
Monstrum	£11.99	75%	£2.99	£9.00
The Solus Project	£14.99	50%	£7.49	£7.50
Dead Secret	£10.99	60%	£4.39	£6.60
Twisted Arrow	£14.99	75%	£3.74	£11.25
Carnival Games® VR	£15.99	75%	£3.99	£12.00
Arcade Saga	£14.99	75%	£3.74	£11.25
Please, Don't Touch Anything 3D	£10.99	60%	£4.39	£6.60
Blue Effect VR	£10.99	50%	£5.49	£5.50
Total	£105.92	66%	£36.22	£69.70

You can pick up some great VR bargains in the sale!

As you can see, the Steam Sales are really the way to build up your VR library whilst minimising your risk. I don't mind paying a good price for a game I genuinely enjoy, but the trouble with the VR market is that it is really still dominated by Indie games developers and, to be brutally honest, there are a lot of short, boring, technically poor and/or "early access" games out there.

I don't mind taking a punt on a VR game for £3.99. At that price, if it turns out to be a bad game, it's only a few quid, whereas if I'd spent £16 on it I'd be more upset. Plus, this is a great chance for me to get some games I can review for my blog, for your pleasure of course! 😀

I considered burning through my newly acquired list of VR games, to give each a couple of hours play and have a chance to review them for you guys so you still had a chance to pick them up in the sale. But, upon reflection, I thought the trouble with that is that some games can seem really fun for the first couple of hours, then you discover that the rest of the game is pretty much the same (like No Man's Sky, a huge disappointment), so I'm not going to do that. If you want to take advantage of the Steam Sales then you'll need to take a punt like I am, but by the time the Steam Winter Sale comes out, I'll have some reviews out.

This game is a bargain at twice the current price!

A final note before I finish. My next post, which will be out today also, is a review of Subnautica. Prior to the Steam sale, this is the only VR game I've actually paid money for, I did so after a lot of research and I paid full price. My next post is a review of this game and it is now in the sale at half price. I was already happy to have bought this game at full price, so I totally recommend you buy Subnautica now whilst the sale is on. The genre is exploration/survival but the water element makes it huge fun!

Game	Original Price	Discount	Sale Price	Saving
Subnautica	£14.99	50%	£7.49	£7.50

I'm working on my Subnautica review to be published today, so keep hitting that refresh button if you are keen to see it!